Hello and welcome back to the Cripple Command Center podcast. My name is Eric Valor and I will be your host for this episode. The Cripple Command Center, or C-to-the-3 (C^3), is where I live, also called The Blue Room. It’s where I make and produce this podcast. It has been a while since I published a podcast. I have had some personal and health issues including one that landed me in the hospital. Afterward I was quite exhausted and needed time to rest and recover. Turns out staying in the hospital is not good for you.
So, now to the news. First, I am pleased to announce that I have self-published a book of my own poetry titled “Hamachi Eyes”,written over the past few decades. It’s on my website under the About Me tab. I also have a bunch of my original food recipes under the same tab so have a look if you’re into the culinary arts. Ironic that I really got into cooking after I could no longer eat. Anyway, the book is about 89 pages of a journey through my interpretations of various experiences.
Next, many of you have heard that Brainstorm will not be releasing its proposed therapy for ALS under the recently enacted Right To Try law also called RTT. I have been against RTT since it was first proposed because I knew that it would be ineffective in anything except reducing the ability of the Food and Drug Administration to properly oversee the safety of the drugs produced for sale by pharmaceutical companies. In fact, RTT is no different from the long-existing Expanded Access Program that the FDA created at the turn of the 1990s in response to the HIV/AIDS crisis.
The only difference between RTT and EAP is that the FDA now has a little less authority to halt experimental drugs and therapies that show issues in patients who obtain them outside of official clinical trials. Pharmaceutical companies have no compulsion to provide their products outside of trial and if they do, the patients obtaining them will be subject to large personal cost. And, according to the history of drugs and therapies in trial for life-threatening diseases for which no truly effective treatment options exist, the treatment probably won’t be effective.
What has happened is that patients, specifically Person(s) with ALS or PALS, have been used by the GOP to advance its decades-long deregulation agenda. I warned of this when it was being presented by PALS and we are seeing now that RTT won’t be effective. The Brainstorm product, Nurown, was the original target of RTT and it will not be provided.
Last, a bit of advice. If you tell a PALS that you love him or her, you better damn well mean it. We already have enough trauma to deal with than to have a mate vacillate and/or suddenly vanish. Nothing can deal a worse blow to the already fragile grasp on hope most PALS have. If you don’t mean it or aren’t fully committed then stay silent. False hope is worse than no hope.
Thanks for tuning in to the C-to-the-3 (C^3) podcast on ericvalor.org. Sorry it was such a short one. I am and ever will be Eric N. Valor, and until next time, breathe easy.
Hello and welcome back to the Cripple Command Center podcast. My name is Eric Valor and I will be your host for this episode. It’s my podcast so I get to hog up all of the minuscule glory from an obscure blog about a very niche subject. I promise I won’t let it go to the wig. On tap for this episode are: An update on the latest Neuraltus NP001 confirmatory Phase 2 trial, the new Brainstorm Phase 3, and a note about two decades’ worth of data on Oregon’s Death With Dignity Act.
But first, I would like to urge my readers and viewers to go to my friend Patrick O’Brien’s GoFundMe page and donate to his new independent film project. Patrick is a PALS like me, totally quadriplegic and on mechanical ventilation to live. Nevertheless, he continues on with his passion for independent filmmaking. His first project after he was diagnosed and became quadriplegic and vented, “Transfatty Lives”, won the TriBeCa Film Festival Audience Award and is available on Netflix and i-Tunes, among others. It’s amazing and I urge you all to watch it.
Another urgent matter is regarding the ALS community in Puerto Rico. As you know, a severe hurricane devastated the island, effectively removing the communications infrastructure. This is especially dangerous for PALS by making it even more difficult for them to obtain the assistance they need. You have no doubt already heard of some patients dying in care facilities because the generators which powered ventilators ran out of fuel.
There are over 200 PALS in Puerto Rico who need assistance. Team Gleason, of which I am a board member, has committed at least $10,000.00 to this specific relief effort. I urge everybody watching, hearing, or reading this to donate. Your contributions will help us reach as many PALS as possible with supplies and equipment. With assistance from groups like Baton Rouge Emergency Aid Coalition, Cajun Airlift and networks of physicians in Puerto Rico and on the mainland, we will coordinate getting relief directly to those with ALS. Please consider donating to help PALS with little resources and little help on the horizon. #NoWhiteFlags https://app.etapestry.com/onlineforms/TeamGleason/gleasondonate.html
OK, to business. Neuraltus began their second Phase 2 trial of NP001 in February on 2017. The trial was to have 120 participants in 18 sites across North America and the 120th patient will have the final dose in December! Results are expected mid-2018. The previous trial “failed” but a post-hoc analysis found a responder group based on a set of inflammatory markers found in the blood and restricted this trial to patients fitting the responder profile. The results this time are expected to be much better.
Next item is the new Brainstorm Phase 3. This trial is the follow-up to the impressive Phase 2B which concluded in July of 2016. In the July 18, 2016 Update from Hope Now For ALS, HNFA issued its review of the Brainstorm data showed remarkable results in a group of patients classified as “Responders” (ALSFRS-R slope improved 100% after treatment compared to a 3-month lead-in observed slope of decline). “Responders” were almost half of the treated group. Their ALSFRS-R scores were significantly better than the placebo group and the surveilled biomarker candidates showed significant improvement. The Phase 3 is a multiple-dose trial where the Phase 2 was a single-dose. The results are expected to be even better, though ALS has shown itself to be quite elusive to hit when previous “slam dunk” treatments were thrown at it. Stay tuned here and to the HNFA website for news as soon as it’s released.
Now for a subject that is intensely personal and not a recommend topic for dinner conversation . It’s definitely a dating taboo. This subject is the Oregon Death With Dignity Act (DWDA) which was passed in 1997. The law, which went into effect in 1998, has strict restrictions on terminally-ill patients who would then request a prescription to end his/her own life on their own terms rather than the much more unpleasant terms dictated by terminal illnesses.
According to the Medscape article which prompted this segment of the podcast:
“To obtain a DWDA prescription, patients must be adults of sound mind, have Oregon residency status, and have a terminal illness diagnosis. In addition, two physicians must confirm the patient’s diagnosis and prognosis, the patient must be offered hospice care, and the patient must make one witnessed written request and two oral requests at least 15 days apart.”
It’s a very common-sense approach to ensure only those truly with a terminal illness have access to this program and that people requesting it are not in a state of undue stress or confusion. According to the 20 years of data compiled, the program is a total success. This is where we get into danger of ruining Thanksgiving dinner – especially when Drunk Uncle gets his inevitable too many beers and bourbons before the turkey is even out of the oven and resting.
The issue is being discussed in every individual state and on the federal level. There are many points of resistance, including religious groups and people who have had the cultural stigma of suicide ingrained in their lives. But is it really suicide if one ONLY has a medically-verified shortened life of suffering and loss of personal dignity? Isn’t it better to go out while you still have your human dignity, where family and friends can remember you whole and relatively hearty? These are questions which only the individual patients can answer for themselves.
I made my decision because I knew that I could suck the marrow from he bones of technology and life a full life full of triumph and tragedy, love and loss, creation and oblivion. I have done all that rather more intensely in my shortly over a decade of living with ALS than the previous nearly 4 decades of healthy living. But I feel that every citizen of the United States should have the right to make this decision for themselves. Adults of sound mind should be allowed to be the masters of their own lives. We do not have the luxury of any opinion about when, where, how, and by whom we are brought into this world. It’s the ultimate indignity to be denied the ability to choose our own terms of exit after tragic illness sets the date. However, this is an individual’s choice. I invite discussion on the Comments Section following each text transcript on my website.
I think 2018 is going to be a landmark year in the otherwise long and somber history of ALS. The previous clinical trials of Brainstorm’s Nurown and Neuraltus’ NP001 have had results that were much more remarkable than any in ALS history and, although history has been brutal with Phase 3 failures, there’s no reason to believe that these Phase 3s will be any different from their previous results. I believe this even more since sub-groups of PALS have been identified as very likely to respond to treatment, something not done in past clinical trials for other ALS treatments. We now have two “Real Deal” prospective treatment options going for registration (known to people not in the clinical trial business as approval) which should soon provide effective treatment for many PALS, finally extending lives in meaningful quantities. And for the unlucky among us, the Death With Dignity issue has become a national debate. With excellent data such as those coming from Oregon, hopefully it will become a nationally-recognized right for those of us unfortunate to contract a fatal disease to control our own destinies.
But like everything, PALS will need to go out and get these things for themselves. If Neuraltus and Brainstorm do decide to apply for registration, they will need our help by showing our support for approval and demanding FDA follow through. Likewise, we must also forcefully demand that lawmakers recognize our natural-born rights to control our own lives. Again, like how every gain PALS have made came from one or a few of us starting a small movement, with more joining in and staying active until the goal was achieved, we together can always achieve our goals. Not bad for a bunch of people confined to wheelchairs and beds who cannot physically speak. With a little clever use of technology we are still very potent advocates for ourselves.
A parting point is a political one. It has to do with the new Republican tax bill recently introduced in Congress. One particularly problematic issue with the bill, among multiple others, is the elimination of the Orphan Drug Tax Credit (ODTC). According to NORD, the National Organization for Rare Disorders:
“The ODTC allows drug manufacturers to claim a tax credit of 50 percent of the costs of clinical research and testing of orphan drugs. The ODTC is part of a package of provisions enacted in 1983 in the Orphan Drug Act (ODA) that provide incentives for drug companies to develop products for rare diseases. This legislation has been extremely successful, resulting in over 600 therapies for rare diseases coming to market in the last 35 years.
Without the Orphan Drug Tax Credit, approximately 33 percent fewer orphan therapies would have been developed, and 33 percent fewer orphan therapies will be developed going forward if the tax credit is repealed. This means that at least 10 fewer therapies would come to market for rare diseases each year, only exacerbating the stark need for rare disease treatments even further.”
This is a serious issue for developing treatments not only ALS but all other rare diseases. This is simply unacceptable for not just the patient community but all of America. Giving companies incentives to develop treatments for rare diseases creates jobs and innovation. And, when effective treatments are found, they create economic boosts from the sustained new jobs associated with the new treatment’s production and distribution. But primarily the patients could remain healthy and continue fully participating in the local and national economies. The ODTC is not a “loophole” and eliminating it is penny-wise but pound foolish, paying for tax cuts by eliminating excellent investments in the future of America.
Please help stop this by telling Congress that this is unacceptable. The ODTC is one of the only tax credits that actually saves lives. Tell your Senators and Representative to oppose repealing the Orphan Drug Tax Credit, and stand up for the 95 percent of rare disease patients still searching for a treatment.
I would be remiss if I did not remind my viewers, readers, and listeners that open enrollment for health insurance plans administered under the Affordable Care Act (ACA, also colloquially known as Obamacare) runs from November 1st to December 15th. Certain states are open longer – check your state exchange website for the dates you need to know. This is half the length of open enrollment in previous years because the Trump Administration cut it from 3 months to 6 weeks (a month and a half). Trump also decimated the advertising budget, so people needing coverage under the ACA might not be made sufficiently aware of the new shorter schedule. So, remember this year to get your enrollment completed before December 15th. Don’t wait until the last minute – take some time to take care of yourself today. December 15th is the deadline so make sure your enrollment is complete with plenty of time left. Log on to either your state exchange or the national website and make sure you’re covered by the plan of your choice before December 15th.
That’s this episode of the C-to-the-3 podcast on ericvalor.org. I have been and ever will be Eric N. Valor. Until next time, keep breathing easy.
I am re-releasing an older video I did with a new somewhat tighter look and some upgraded language (words I never liked when I originally released it). Essentially, nothing has changed in 6 years since 2011 to 2017. Radicava was approved for use in the USA, but it only works in very recently diagnosed patients and only for about a year. I classify it with Rilutek as a medication with a rather modest effectiveness. No truly effective and approved treatment exists yet for ALS.
And PALS are still being forced to make the terrifying and grisly choice between bankrupting their families merely for the privilege of living or just accepting a rapidly accelerated death where one morning their children or spouses would find them cold, pale, and never to wake again. Everything is covered by Medicare except the people required for being close by for the inevitable situation of something happening with the ventilator – normal moisture or mucus buildup, the air hose popping off, or something drastic going wrong with the machine – any of which mean death in minutes. Immediate family CANNOT be caregivers because the stress is just too great already. The health consequences would splinter a family at a time when being close together is the most important.
It is despicable that even when new treatment options which promise significant extension of life for PALS that they may be unable to enjoy that gift with their families.
Hello and welcome back to the ericvalor.org Blogcast Podcast.
My name is Eric Valor and I will be your host for this episode. Please make yourselves comfortable and feel free to order something from the bar.
As my longtime readers know, this is not a political blogcast. The scope of this blogcast is limited to the subject of ALS, living with the disease, research into treatments for ALS, experiences of Person(s) with ALS (PALS), and my personal reflections. I routinely deny requests to “guest blog” general health subjects (also because they are just attempts to spread spam links). But I have to address a subject which affects 17% of our entire economy and the daily lives of 99% of our citizens, and has devastating implications for PALS and others similarly affected by severe conditions. That subject is the long-awaited Republican response to the Patient Affordable Healthcare Act, also known as the Affordable Care Act or more colloquially Obamacare.
On Thursday, June 23rd, 2017, the Republican Senate Majority Leader released a “discussion draft” of their supposedly “better” healthcare plan which was promised to lower medical costs and improve medical care for American citizens, and “rescue” us all from the “disaster” of Obamacare. Just like the ridiculous House bill (which Paul Ryan apparently hurriedly cobbled together over a long weekend), the Senate Better Care Reconciliation Act snatches access to healthcare from, and makes it much more expensive for, tens of millions of Americans. We waited 7 years for this? I call it the anti-healthcare bill.
Republicans incessantly whined for 7 years about how terrible Obamacare was, how they had “a much better plan”, how the ACA was “passed in secret with no hearings, input from Republicans or the public, and was written behind closed doors. Actually it was available online for a year for public comment, had over 100 hearings, and included over 100 Republican amendments. After all that time this embarrassment on paper is the best they can come up with? This naked frontal assault on the poor and middle-class WILL LITERALLY KILL ME and others with ALS and other deadly conditions – all to give around $1 TRILLION to the already-hyper-wealthy. Moreover, it was literally written in complete secrecy behind closed doors (in such secrecy that one of the supposed authors of the bill never saw it until today) and will have no hearings with less than 10 hours of debate and amendments before a vote is called about a week from now. Undoubtedly Senator Tortoise McGee wants to rush this vote before senators go on recess and get an earful from constituents.
Obamacare is NOT “failing” (as Republicans ludicrously tried to proclaim even before ACA went into effect). The reality of the situation is that tens of millions more Americans have access to affordable healthcare. Medical bills are the number 1 cause of bankruptcy in America. And that comes from a lack of insurance.
The ACA is only “failing” in those states which intentionally refused to cooperate with the Medicaid expansion where the federal government paid 100% of the costs for 3 years and thereafter covered 90%. These same states also refused to set up state exchanges, forcing residents onto the federal one. No wonder they have problems – and all just so Republican governors and legislatures wanted to score political points at the expense of their citizens. People may try to say this is just partisan finger-pointing but unfortunately for their view it’s also true. In the states which cooperated and implemented the provisions of the ACA it’s working out wonderfully.
The ACA in its final form was not designed to lower medical costs because that was negotiated out of the bill by Republicans and Pharma lobbyists. But it did, in fact, reduce the rate at which America’s healthcare expenditures increased, and it created significant affordable relief for tens of millions who would otherwise continue without care until forced to show up in the ER with a catastrophic condition. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.
“First, the BCRA will cut hundreds of billions of dollars of Federal funding from the Medicaid program by instituting per capita caps and optional block grants. Medicaid is a critical lifeline to millions of individuals with rare diseases across the United States. … State programs for Medicaid home and community-based services (HCBS) waivers (1915 waivers) may also be jeopardized due to financial constraints.
Second, the BCRA … would phase out Medicaid expansion starting in 2020 and concluding in 2024, likely leaving many individuals with rare diseases without health insurance.
Third, the BCRA does not adhere to several of our principles relating to prohibiting discrimination against individuals with pre-existing conditions. … [The BCRA] would still bring back annual and lifetime limits and limitless out-of-pocket costs by allowing states to amend the Essential Health Benefits (EHB) through section 1332 waivers. These vital protections … would therefore be removed if a state opts out via a 1332 waiver.
Finally, the BCRA does nothing to incentivize healthy individuals to enter the individual market and help stabilize premiums by offsetting the cost of more expensive individuals.”
I would also like to quote Judith Stein, the Executive Director for the Center for Medicare Advocacy (CMA):
“Never in 40 years of Medicare & Health care advocacy have I witnessed the kind of secrecy, and determination to take away health coverage we are witnessing today. A health care bill would strengthen coverage and delivery programs. This bill gratuitously weakens Medicare, decimates Medicaid, and guts insurance for over 20 million people.”
According to CMA, the BCRA includes:
The end of Medicaid expansion: Millions will lose coverage.
Medicaid per capita caps: Cuts would actually deepen over time.
Repeal of Medicare tax increase: Undermines Medicare’s finances.
This is a statement I added to a change.org petition calling for a “Medicare for All” program:
“I am currently living only because of Medicare and Medicaid. I have Lou Gehrig’s Disease, and used to be a top-10% wage earner. The disease forced me into bankruptcy slightly before I was even middle-aged. The United States is the wealthiest country in global history, and we have much more than enough taxation right now to pay for guaranteed healthcare. Medicare functions at a much higher efficiency than any other private for-profit insurance, because it doesn’t have a powerful incentive to maximize profit by denying me the services I paid for. Even with “Medicare for all” as a basic level of healthcare, there is still plenty of market left-over for private insurance for things like elective procedures.
It’s time for our public tax dollars to be applied toward services for the public, not for the enrichment of some private corporation. The last year has seen a massive awakening in public attention toward healthcare. If you are not aware of this by now, it’s because you are not paying attention to the voices of your constituents. But we are, and are very much aware of your actions (or lack thereof).”
Please consider signing the petition. It’s not likely to be successful by itself but it will show Congress that there is significant resistance to the GOP plan and that the right move is to actually expand Medicare in order to ensure the right of healthcare for all citizens.
The BCRA is a hideous piece of legislation that severely jeopardizes the poor, the elderly, and the handicapped like me. It’s basically a tax cut for the hyper-wealthy that is paid for by the suffering and death, yes death, of people coping with ALS and other deadly conditions that were stricken through no fault of their own. It’s a serious threat to my life and the lives of many of my friends. That required me to make this political statement.
Thank you for watching and please vote carefully and diligently in 2018. It can change lives in a major way. In the meantime, please contact your senators immediately and urge them to vote “No” on the BCRA. Until next time, keep breathing easy.
There has been a lot of recent controversy surrounding the experimental treatment in clinical trials known as GM604. A lot of misinformation has been tossed around on both sides of the issue. I want to beg your attention for a little while to explain what’s really going on.
First, as many of you know, I was the single late-stage PALS who received GM6 in compassionate use. The intent behind this was to get a look at differences in biomarker candidate levels between earlier-stage and late-stage PALS. Any outward physical manifestation of improved condition noticed would be a bonus and, due to my advanced condition, no improvement in condition was expected. Nevertheless, Genervon and I came up with the idea to try to chart improvements in the tongue. The rationale is that since my tongue is only moderately affected, and because the hypoglossal nerve contains one of the shortest motor neurons in the body, any possible improvement would be noticed there first.
Because of my growing cooperative relationship with Genervon dating back to my first blog post on GM6, I was granted the only Expanded Access outside of trial. They were interested in getting a look at GM6 behavior in late-stage PALS and I had proven to them my organizational skills in preparing my own medical surveillance team and in communications by preparing the mechanism for data capture. Even a single Expanded Access Program can be a burden on such a small company not optimized for such work. My knowledge and experience gained over the past few years was of considerable help in filling out and transmitting (and following up on) my own paperwork.
Thousands of single Expanded Access requests would be overly burdensome and even if Genervon enlisted the help of the ALS Emergency Treatment Fund, the maximum number of patients who would be able to participate would be measured in the few hundreds. Not only would patients have to pay for drug but would also have to pay for their own medical surveillance team and at least one hospital visit for the first infusion (this alone represents several thousand dollars). If you are required to give biological samples, the cost tops $10,000.
Genervon shared with me much of the top-level data from the Phase 2 to compare against my own data. Even though the trial population was small, the data were stronger in separation between treatment/placebo cohorts than in any legitimate trial results I had seen before. And GM6 was demonstrated safe over a much larger group spread over three different neurological diseases (including ALS) plus a healthy safety group. For these reasons I suggested to and worked with Genervon on applying for the FDA Accelerated Approval Program in order to get GM6 to all PALS paid for by insurance and Medicare.
And thus began the shitstorm…
Researchers, neurologists, and leaders of certain advocacy organizations who believe in the FDA’s 60 year old regulatory formula – comprised of designing, completing, and analyzing Phase 1, 2, 3 trials over a period of 5-15 years – are failing in their proclaimed mission. They simply have to stop regarding patients as helpless victims willing to eat rat poison if someone said it cured ALS, Genervon as somehow the 19th Century snake oil salesman, and themselves as the White Knight riding to our rescue. The very process of obtaining an experimental drug requires a lot of medical oversight, which we appreciate and rely on. However, patients are intelligent adults whose only desire is to change the status quo of scientific research for the benefit of both the current and future generations of PALS.
The 1992 FDA Accelerated Approval Program (AAP) was designed to meet the needs of patient populations where there is an urgent and unmet need. In 2012, Congress passed and the President signed into law the Food and Drug Administration Safety and Innovation Act (FDASIA), strengthening the agency’s ability to advance public health by equipping the FDA with tools intended to expedite the development and review of innovative new medicines that address certain unmet medical needs. Among the objectives, Title IX expanded the scope of products that qualify for accelerated approval. Specific language in this law states that the FDA is to incorporate novel approaches to the review of surrogate endpoints based on pathophysiologic and pharmacologic evidence in such guidance, especially in instances where the low prevalence of a disease renders the existence or collection of other types of data unlikely or impractical. It is obvious that Congress and the President had in mind diseases just like ALS when passing and signing FDASIA into law, yet the FDA has done very little to incorporate these guidelines.
With Congress now discussing the 21st Century Cures Act, we at Hope Now for ALS believe that we are on the right side of history by insisting that PALS are given opportunities to access new investigational treatments through the FDA’s Accelerated Approval Program which, with its requirement for post-marketing Phase 4 data surveillance to confirm efficacy and safety, will continue to provide invaluable data on new treatments for ALS. As most patients are ineligible for standard clinical trials, this is our only option to contribute to research that will provide the same data at a faster rate among a larger population of patients – providing much needed data on subsets of the patient population. The Phase 4 requirements of Accelerated Approval also have the ability to save billions of dollars in research that is better spent developing more new and better investigational treatments for a myriad of neurological conditions.
I will grant that the biomarker candidates are new and not yet “proven”, but FDA did allow them as endpoints in the Phase 2. They are not brand-new fabrications by Genervon and are backed by a lot of recent research by respected researchers. And they were all quite uniform in response to GM6 while the placebo group all continued in the abnormal direction. In my n=1 case report the biomarker candidates sometimes went in the reverse direction, but ALWAYS TOWARD NORMAL LEVELS. This is a great indication that GM6 promotes neuronal homeostasis – the holy grail for ALS research.
The Phase 2 was indeed also only a very small population, and in previous ALS trials of similar size it was impossible to collect reliable efficacy data in such a small cohort. However, this trial was very different from previous trials. The effect registered was much larger than in previous such trials (especially dexpramipexole) and was backed up by multiple secondary measurements not subject to any placebo effect. The combination of surprisingly-large effect size and objective biological markers sets this aside from previous trials (which also used the ALSFRS almost exclusively). There was an erroneous though well-intentioned attempt to use the released FVC information as evidence of poor trial design. However, the comparison used a very inappropriate analogy population and was built on an assumption based on incorrect data.
I do have serious issues with a point used in arguments against GM6: The lithium debacle. The media reports which came out obviously created a lot of excitement within the patient community. Our first reaction was asking and pleading the research community to quickly follow up with more trials to confirm that study and the response from the research committee was absolute disinterest. Therefore the patient community took it upon themselves to create a verification study, which we did. We did *NOT* merely go out and start using lithium off-label. In fact, it was only after our trial data was being released that the research community decided to do a confirmation study. By then we had already demonstrated that lithium had no effect in ALS and begged the research community to not waste time and millions of dollars.
But again, the research community ignored the patient community.
The Hope Now for ALS movement isn’t for GM6 to skip the regulatory process. It’s to get FDA to use its existing programs and Congressional mandate to provide potentially life-saving treatment to PALS. This is especially important now that truly-effective treatments are very near (including NP001, Neurown, etc.). Caution is obviously warranted but ALS is a race against a clock that doesn’t care. More aggressive strategy is thus required which necessitates a little less caution and a lot more courage.
In summary, the facts are:
Genervon asked FDA for Accelerated Approval at the post-Phase 2 meeting where they presented the complete trial data plus the case report for my Compassionate Use project. I know this to be true because I co-wrote the cover letter to the data package and it specifically asked for Accelerated Approval (and it was me who urged Genervon to pursue AAP).
The FDA should have responded with specific instructions on how to file. They did not and thus we were all left in a state of confusion. Then FDA took the unusual step of calling on Genervon to publicly release proprietary data. Genervon has no duty to do so and FDA has no authority to make such a request.
Genervon has perfectly complied with law and regulation. All they want is to help and they believe GM6 can do that. The data so far looks good (and I can say that, having actually seen it where all others commenting otherwise have not). It’s not a slam-dunk, but it’s positive and safe enough that I think all PALS should have access to it – not just those eligible for clinical trial.
The FDA Accelerated Approval Program, in place since 1992 to deal with fatal diseases for which no other treatments exist, is the best way to save lives. It opens access WHILE CLINICAL TRIALS STILL CONTINUE. It’s used for cancer and other diseases with less-severe prognosis. Why not ALS?
GM6 has a perfect safety record in over 50 patients across 3 separate neurological conditions plus a healthy initial safety cohort.
This is about patients deciding for themselves what risk to take in treatment. This is NOT about a company trying to avoid the clinical trial process or enrich itself on patients desperation. The AAP is an existing program which gives patients access to potentially life-saving treatment while collecting the valuable efficacy data.
Contrast Genervon’s completely legal and transparent actions to other companies marketing unproven products such as lunasin and aimspro directly to patients using email. Those companies use slick pitches with “proof” based purely on non-accepted metrics and anecdotes.
The movement behind GM6 is entirely grassroots.
The above are facts. All of the “expert opinion” going around is just biased speculation.
The White House has an online petition system where citizens can weigh in on issues before the President. If the petition gets 25,000 “signatures” within 30 days of it being created, it will be presented to the President where it must become part of the policy discussion. This is a great way for We, The People, to address and direct our government (especially in these times of corporate-captured government).
There is a petition currently in circulation to demand that scientific research paid for with taxpayer dollars remain freely accessible to anyone wishing to read it. The current signature count is just shy of 16,400 and I strongly urge my readers to sign and share this petition by email and/or social media. Working together we can ensure our intellectual property isn’t stolen and we are then charged for its return by the very thieves who stole it.
I rely quite a bit on public access to research papers in order to better understand ALS and to bring you this blog, for what it’s worth. The US Taxpayers, through NIH grants, fund quite a lot of the medical research that is done in the United States. If we paid for this research, we should be able to have access to the results (which, again, we already paid for).
However, a bill is being introduced to take that away. The bill is sponsored by Carolyn Maloney (D – NY) and Darrel Issa (R – CA). Ms. Maloney received the most individual political contributions of the medical publishing giant Elsevier in 2011. Mr. Issa is also on the contribution list. Once again we see that corporate money in politics does not favor the citizens. This is not a political blog so I will cease my digression.
Clearly this is a threat to public access to knowledge which the public already owns. This public knowledge benefits people like me and you as well as institutions such as schools. If you want to retain your rights to access that for which you already paid, action is needed. I urge you to contact your Congresscritter and urge him or her to kill HR 3699. You could also contact Congresswoman Maloney to express your opinion of this bill:
Twitter: @RepMaloney @CarolynBMaloney
Email: Use this form
Don’t let corporations steal from you and charge you for the favor.